Costs & ROI · 6 min read

How to choose an AEO or GEO agency: 15 questions to ask

A buyer’s guide to choosing an AI search agency, with the questions that separate specialists from rebranded SEO packages.

By the AEO GEO Marketing team · Updated

Key takeaways
  • Many agencies now sell AI search; few can show measured citation results.
  • Ask how they track citations, which engines and which prompts.
  • Look for clear deliverables, realistic timelines and transparent reporting.
  • Avoid guarantees, secret tactics and mass-produced AI content.
  • Start with an audit or short pilot to test fit.

Why choosing carefully matters

Since AI search became mainstream, many agencies have added “GEO”, “AEO” or “AI SEO” to their services. Some have genuine expertise and measured results. Others have simply renamed existing SEO packages. Choosing the wrong partner can waste months and budget while competitors establish themselves in AI answers.

The questions below help you assess any agency, including ours.

1. How do you define AEO and GEO?

A good agency explains clearly how AEO (making content extractable as answers) and GEO (making a brand trusted and cited by generative engines) differ from traditional SEO and how they work together. Vague answers or buzzwords without substance are a warning sign.

2. Can you show current AI citations for clients?

Ask for examples, such as screenshots or reports showing clients cited in Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT or Perplexity for meaningful queries. Rankings charts alone do not prove AI search expertise. Respect confidentiality, but expect some evidence.

3. Which AI engines do you track, and how?

Ask which engines they monitor (Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, and others relevant to your markets), how they run prompts consistently and how they handle variability. A credible process uses a stable prompt set, consistent settings and trend reporting.

4. How will you choose the prompts to track?

The prompt set should reflect real buyer questions and commercial priorities, not just branded queries. Ask how they research prompts and whether you will agree the list together.

5. What does the first 90 days look like?

A good agency can describe a concrete 90-day plan: audit, technical fixes, content priorities, entity and profile work, authority building and the first measurement point. Lack of a clear plan suggests a generic approach.

6. What exactly will you deliver each month?

Ask for specific deliverables: number of pages created or updated, technical tasks, outreach activities, reports and calls. Clear deliverables make it possible to hold the agency accountable.

7. Who will do the work?

Find out who will work on your account and their experience. Will senior strategists be involved, or is work handed to junior staff or outsourced? Meet the people if possible.

8. How do you create content?

Ask how content is researched, written, reviewed and optimised. Do they involve your experts? How do they use AI tools? Content that is mass-produced by AI without expertise rarely earns citations and can damage trust.

9. How do you build authority?

GEO depends on independent signals: reviews, mentions, coverage and links. Ask what authority-building work is included, such as digital PR, review generation or partnerships, and how they avoid manipulative tactics.

10. How do you handle technical SEO?

AI visibility depends on crawlability, structured data, speed and site architecture. Ask whether the agency handles technical work directly, advises your developers, or ignores it.

11. How do you report results?

Ask to see a sample report. It should cover citation and mention share by engine, competitor comparison, AI referral traffic, conversions and next steps. Reporting should connect activities to business outcomes.

12. What results are realistic, and when?

Honest agencies set expectations: first citations for specific questions within weeks to a few months, broader gains over six to twelve months. Be cautious of guaranteed results or very short timelines.

13. What are the contract terms?

Understand the minimum term, notice period, ownership of content and accounts, and what happens if you leave. You should own everything created for you.

14. How do you price your services?

Ask for transparent pricing and what is included. Compare proposals on deliverables and outcomes rather than headline price. Ask about additional costs such as tools, translation or PR expenses.

15. Do you understand my industry and markets?

AI search varies by sector and country. Regulated industries require compliance awareness; international markets require language and local engine knowledge. Ask about relevant experience.

Red flags

  • Guaranteed rankings or citations.
  • Secret methods or “hacks” to manipulate AI.
  • No evidence of AI citation tracking.
  • Mass-produced content as the main deliverable.
  • Unclear pricing or deliverables.
  • Long contracts with no performance reviews.
  • Reluctance to share who does the work.

Start with an audit or pilot

A practical way to test an agency is to start with a paid audit or a short pilot. You will see their analysis, communication and recommendations before committing to a long engagement. A good audit should be valuable even if you do not continue.

What a good proposal looks like

A strong proposal starts with your business goals and the questions your buyers ask, not with a list of services. It includes findings from an initial review, a prioritised 90-day plan, clear monthly deliverables, the engines and prompts to be tracked, reporting format, the team involved, pricing with all costs, contract terms and how success will be judged. If a proposal could be sent unchanged to any business, it probably will not address your needs.

Questions to ask references

If an agency offers references, ask them: What was the situation before? What did the agency actually do? How did they communicate? Were deadlines met? What results were achieved, and how were they measured? What would you change? Would you hire them again? Reference calls often reveal more about working style than any sales meeting.

Specialist versus full-service agency

A specialist AI search agency brings depth in AEO and GEO but may rely on partners for design, development or paid media. A full-service agency offers everything under one roof but may have less depth in AI search. The right choice depends on your existing team and needs. Whichever you choose, make sure someone is accountable for AI visibility outcomes, not just activities.

How to evaluate the first three months

After three months, review the engagement against what was agreed. Were deliverables completed on time and to a good standard? Has the technical foundation improved? Are there first citations or mentions for priority prompts? Is reporting clear and honest about what is and is not working? Do you trust the team’s judgement? Early results may be modest, but the direction of travel and the quality of work should be clear. If both are poor, it is reasonable to change course.

Cultural fit and communication

Technical skill is not enough; you will work closely with the agency for months. Notice how they communicate during the sales process. Do they listen and ask good questions about your business? Do they explain things clearly without jargon? Are they honest about limitations? Do they respond promptly? Agree communication channels and meeting rhythms upfront, and make sure there is a named person accountable for your account. Good communication often predicts good results.

Ownership and access

Before signing, confirm that all accounts, content, data and code will be owned by your business. Analytics, Search Console, Business Profile and ad accounts should be in your name, with the agency given user access. This protects you if the relationship ends and avoids losing historical data.

Running a pilot

A pilot of two to three months on a defined scope, such as one service line or one market, lets you evaluate an agency with limited risk. Agree the goals, deliverables and metrics in advance, and review results honestly at the end. A good agency will welcome this approach, because it builds trust on evidence rather than promises.

Key terms in this guide

  • AEO (Answer Engine Optimization): The practice of structuring content so search and answer engines can extract it as the direct answer to a question, in featured snippets, voice assistants and AI-generated answers.
  • GEO (Generative Engine Optimization): The practice of making a brand and its content trustworthy and quotable enough to be cited inside answers written by generative AI engines such as Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini.
  • AI Overviews: AI-generated summaries that appear at the top of some Google search results, with links to the web pages used as sources.
  • AI Mode: A conversational search experience in Google that answers complex questions with AI-generated responses and follow-up questions, citing web sources.
  • RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation): A technique where an AI system retrieves relevant documents, usually from a search index, and uses them to write a grounded answer. Most AI search engines use a form of RAG, which is why being retrievable matters.
  • Citation: A link or reference to a source shown inside an AI-generated answer. Citations are the main unit of success in GEO.
  • Entity: A distinct, identifiable thing, such as a company, person, place or product, that search engines and AI models recognise and store facts about.
  • AI referral traffic: Website visits that come from AI assistants and engines such as chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai, gemini.google.com and copilot.microsoft.com.

How AEO GEO Marketing can help

If you would rather have specialists handle this, these services cover the work described in this guide:

AI SEO & Generative Engine Optimization

Get cited in Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT & Perplexity. The new search visibility standard. It includes geo / aeo full audit, ai overview citation strategy, entity authority building and more, from $800/mo.

AI Visibility Audit

A full report on how AI engines see your brand, with a prioritised 90-day action plan. It includes prompt testing, competitor benchmark, technical ai readiness and more, from $750 one-off.

White-Label AEO & GEO for Agencies

Sell AEO and GEO under your own brand while our specialists do the work. It includes branded audits, fulfilment team, branded reporting and more, from $1,000/mo.

Not sure where to start? The free 48-hour AI snapshot shows where AI engines cite you today.

Frequently asked questions

Should I use my existing SEO agency for GEO?

If they can answer the questions above convincingly and show AI citation results, possibly. Otherwise, consider a specialist or a combined arrangement.

Is a cheaper agency always worse?

Not always, but very low prices often mean limited deliverables or automated content. Compare scope and evidence.

How many agencies should I speak to?

Two or three is usually enough to compare approaches and pricing.

Can a freelancer do GEO?

Experienced freelancers can do excellent work, especially for smaller businesses. Larger programmes may need a team covering content, technical and PR.

Continue with these guides:

Or see how we put this into practice:

Want this done for you?

Get a free 48-hour GEO audit that shows exactly where AI engines cite you — and where they cite your competitors.