By the AEO GEO Marketing team · Updated
- An AI search audit covers access, content, entity, authority, measurement and conversion.
- Start with crawler access and indexing, which block everything else.
- Answer-first content and accurate facts make pages citable.
- Off-site signals such as reviews and mentions are as important as on-site work.
- Re-run the audit every six months to track progress.
How to use this checklist
This checklist covers the main factors that affect whether AI engines can find, understand, trust and cite your business. Work through each section, mark each item as done, partly done or not done, and note the evidence. Prioritise fixes that block visibility entirely, such as crawler access and indexing, then work on content, entity and authority improvements.
You can complete a basic audit yourself in a day. A detailed audit with prompt testing across engines and competitors takes longer but gives a clearer picture of where to focus.
Section 1: Crawler access (items 1–7)
- robots.txt allows Googlebot and Bingbot.
- robots.txt allows the AI search crawlers you want, such as OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot and Claude-SearchBot.
- Your policy for training crawlers (GPTBot, ClaudeBot, Google-Extended, CCBot) is a deliberate choice.
- CDN and firewall bot settings do not block wanted crawlers.
- Server logs show successful visits from search and AI crawlers.
- Important pages return a 200 status, not errors or redirect chains.
- No accidental noindex tags on important pages.
Section 2: Indexing and rendering (items 8–13)
- Key pages are indexed in Google (check Search Console).
- Key pages are indexed in Bing (check Bing Webmaster Tools).
- Main content is present in the HTML source, not only after JavaScript runs.
- Canonical tags point to the correct versions.
- XML sitemaps list important pages and are submitted to Google and Bing.
- IndexNow is set up where supported, so updates are discovered quickly.
Section 3: Content structure (items 14–20)
- Priority questions each have a clear page or section.
- Sections start with direct answers.
- Headings describe the questions they answer.
- Facts include specific numbers, dates and units.
- Comparisons and specifications use tables or lists.
- Long pages have a summary at the top.
- Each section makes sense on its own.
Section 4: Expertise and trust (items 21–26)
- Important content has named authors with credentials.
- Author pages exist and link to professional profiles.
- Content cites reputable sources.
- Pages show last-updated dates and are current.
- Company information, contact details and policies are easy to find.
- Regulated sectors display licences, registrations and disclaimers.
Section 5: Entity and structured data (items 27–31)
- Organization schema with logo, contact details and sameAs links.
- Consistent business name, description and details across the web.
- Service, Product, Article, Person and FAQPage schema where relevant.
- LocalBusiness schema for each location.
- Structured data validates without errors and matches visible content.
Section 6: Off-site authority (items 32–36)
- Google Business Profile and other maps profiles are complete and accurate.
- Reviews are recent, detailed and answered on key platforms.
- Listings in relevant directories and associations are consistent.
- The brand is mentioned in publications AI engines cite for your topics.
- Experts appear in media, podcasts or events in their own names.
Section 7: Measurement (items 37–40)
- A fixed prompt set covers your priority questions.
- Citations and mentions are tracked across key engines monthly.
- AI referral traffic is separated in analytics.
- Conversions from AI and organic traffic are measured and reviewed.
Scoring your audit
Give each item a score of 0 (not done), 1 (partly done) or 2 (done). The maximum is 80. Scores below 40 usually indicate fundamental issues with access, content or entity information. Scores between 40 and 60 suggest solid foundations with gaps in authority or measurement. Scores above 60 indicate a strong base where competitive content and PR become the main levers. Use the scores per section to decide where to focus.
Prompt testing as part of the audit
Alongside the checklist, test real prompts. Ask 20 to 100 buyer questions across Google AI Overviews or AI Mode, ChatGPT and Perplexity. Record whether you are mentioned or cited, which competitors appear and which sources are used. This shows the outcome of all the factors above and helps prioritise. If competitors are consistently cited from a particular source, that source becomes a target.
Turning findings into a plan
Group fixes into three categories:
- Blockers: access, indexing and rendering issues. Fix immediately.
- Foundations: content structure, expertise signals, schema and entity consistency. Fix within the first one to two months.
- Growth: authority building, new content and PR. Ongoing work.
Assign owners and deadlines, and schedule a follow-up audit in six months.
A worked example: a regional law firm audit
A regional law firm scores 34 out of 80. Its CDN blocks several AI crawlers, practice-area pages have no named authors, the firm’s address differs across directories and it has few recent reviews. Prompt testing shows competitors cited for most local legal questions. The firm unblocks crawlers, adds lawyer profiles and authorship, fixes listings, starts a review process and rewrites five key pages answer-first. Six months later it scores 62, and it is mentioned for a growing share of its priority prompts.
Common audit mistakes
- Testing only branded prompts.
- Ignoring Bing indexing.
- Checking the rendered page but not the HTML source.
- Overlooking firewall settings.
- Treating the audit as a one-off instead of a recurring check.
- Producing findings without prioritised actions.
Tools you need for the audit
Most of this audit can be done with free tools: Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools for indexing and performance, your browser’s “view source” and developer tools for rendering checks, Google’s Rich Results Test and the Schema Markup Validator for structured data, your analytics platform for AI referrals, and the AI engines themselves for prompt testing. A site crawler helps with larger sites by finding noindex tags, broken links, duplicate titles and orphan pages at scale.
Auditing competitors
Run the most important parts of the checklist on two or three competitors who appear in AI answers where you do not. Look at their page structure, authorship, schema, reviews and media coverage. You will usually see clear differences: a competitor with a detailed pricing page, more recent reviews or coverage in the publications engines cite. These differences become concrete actions for your own plan.
Auditing a multi-location business
For businesses with many locations, sample several locations across regions and check their Business Profiles, location pages, reviews and local citations individually. Problems often vary by location: one branch may have outdated hours, another inconsistent addresses or few reviews. Create a location scorecard so managers can see and fix their own issues.
Presenting audit results
Present results in a format decision-makers can act on: an overall score, section scores, the five most important findings with evidence (such as screenshots of AI answers citing competitors), and a prioritised plan with owners and timelines. Avoid long lists of minor issues without priorities; they make it harder to get the important work done.
Re-auditing and tracking progress
Repeat the checklist and prompt tests every six months using the same method, so results are comparable. Track section scores over time alongside citation share, AI referrals and conversions. Improvements in the checklist should be followed by improvements in visibility; if not, revisit priorities, especially content relevance and off-site authority.
Quick wins from the checklist
Some items can be fixed in an afternoon: unblocking crawlers, submitting sitemaps to Bing, adding Organization schema, correcting Business Profile details and adding authors to key pages. Do these first; they often produce visible improvements within weeks.
What the checklist does not cover
No checklist captures everything. Market dynamics, the quality and originality of your expertise, product strengths, pricing and customer experience all influence whether engines and people recommend you. Use the checklist to remove obstacles and strengthen signals, but remember that being genuinely the best answer for your audience is what sustains visibility.
Key terms in this guide
- AI Overviews: AI-generated summaries that appear at the top of some Google search results, with links to the web pages used as sources.
- AI Mode: A conversational search experience in Google that answers complex questions with AI-generated responses and follow-up questions, citing web sources.
- RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation): A technique where an AI system retrieves relevant documents, usually from a search index, and uses them to write a grounded answer. Most AI search engines use a form of RAG, which is why being retrievable matters.
- Citation: A link or reference to a source shown inside an AI-generated answer. Citations are the main unit of success in GEO.
- Citation share: The percentage of tracked questions for which a brand is cited by a given AI engine. It is the GEO equivalent of share of voice.
- Entity: A distinct, identifiable thing, such as a company, person, place or product, that search engines and AI models recognise and store facts about.
- Schema markup: Code, usually JSON-LD, that describes a page’s content in a standard vocabulary from Schema.org, helping engines understand businesses, services, people, FAQs and more.
- FAQPage schema: Structured data that marks up a list of questions and answers on a page. It helps engines identify clear question-and-answer pairs.
How AEO GEO Marketing can help
If you would rather have specialists handle this, these services cover the work described in this guide:
AI SEO & Generative Engine Optimization
Get cited in Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT & Perplexity. The new search visibility standard. It includes geo / aeo full audit, ai overview citation strategy, entity authority building and more, from $800/mo.
Web Design & Development
Performance-first websites built for conversion, speed and AI search visibility. It includes ux & visual design, core web vitals engineering, schema-ready architecture and more, from $1,500/mo.
AI Visibility Audit
A full report on how AI engines see your brand, with a prioritised 90-day action plan. It includes prompt testing, competitor benchmark, technical ai readiness and more, from $750 one-off.
Not sure where to start? The free 48-hour AI snapshot shows where AI engines cite you today.
Frequently asked questions
How long does an AI search audit take?
A basic self-audit can take a day. A detailed audit with prompt testing and competitor analysis usually takes one to two weeks.
Can I do the audit myself?
Yes, using this checklist and free tools such as Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools and schema validators. A professional audit adds depth and benchmarking.
How often should I audit?
Every six months, or after major site changes, migrations or shifts in your market.
What is the most common problem?
Accidentally blocked crawlers and content that does not answer questions directly are among the most common issues.
Related guides and services
Continue with these guides:
- 15 GEO mistakes that keep brands out of AI answers: The most common mistakes we see when businesses try to improve AI visibility, and how to fix each one.
- What is GEO? The 2026 guide to Generative Engine Optimization: GEO is how brands get cited inside AI answers. Here is how it works, why it matters and how to start.
- What is AEO? Answer Engine Optimization explained: Answer engines extract a single best answer. AEO makes sure that answer is yours.
- GEO vs SEO: what changes, what stays the same: Rankings still matter — but being cited now matters more. A practical comparison.
Or see how we put this into practice:
- AI SEO & Generative Engine Optimization: Get cited in Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT & Perplexity. The new search visibility standard.
- Web Design & Development: Performance-first websites built for conversion, speed and AI search visibility.
- AI Visibility Audit: A full report on how AI engines see your brand, with a prioritised 90-day action plan.
Get a free 48-hour GEO audit that shows exactly where AI engines cite you — and where they cite your competitors.
